## Summary
Ensures that we only show supported options:
<img width="1228" alt="Screen Shot 2023-08-28 at 11 03 16 AM"
src="50fb7595-dc30-43d2-a7e4-c0103acc15b9">
For now, I'm not super focused on DRYing up the CLI.
The docs were out of date, and the new version incorporates some
feedback.
I tried to keep the language concise and the information ordered by how
early you need it, so people can get the relevant information quickly
before jumping into the code.
I did some minor format_dev changes for consistency in the docs.
---------
Co-authored-by: Micha Reiser <micha@reiser.io>
**Summary** Some files seems notoriously slow in the formatter (secons in debug mode). This time was however almost exclusively spent in the diff algorithm to collect the similarity index, so i replaced that. I kept `similar` for printing actual diff to avoid rewriting that too, with the disadvantage that we now have to diff libraries in format_dev.
I used this PR to remove the spinner from tracing-indicatif and changed `flamegraph --perfdata perf.data` to `flamegraph --perfdata perf.data --no-inline` as the former wouldn't finish for me on release builds with debug info.
**Summary** This adds the information whether we're in a .py python
source file or in a .pyi stub file to enable people working on #5822 and
related issues.
I'm not completely happy with `Default` for something that depends on
the input.
**Test Plan** None, this is currently unused, i'm leaving this to first
implementation of stub file specific formatting.
---------
Co-authored-by: Micha Reiser <micha@reiser.io>
**Summary** Prompted by
https://github.com/astral-sh/ruff/pull/6257#issuecomment-1661308410, it
tried to make the ecosystem script output on failure better
understandable. All log messages are now written to a file, which is
printed on error. Running locally progress is still shown.
Looking through the log output i saw that we currently log syntax errors
in input, which is confusing because they aren't actual errors, but we
don't check that these files don't change due to parser regressions or
improvements. I added `--files-with-errors` to catch that.
**Test Plan** CI
## Summary
[tracing](https://github.com/tokio-rs/tracing) is library for logging,
tracing and related features that has a large ecosystem. Using
[tracing-subscriber](https://docs.rs/tracing-subscriber) and
[tracing-indicatif](https://github.com/emersonford/tracing-indicatif),
we get a nice logging output that you can configure with `RUST_LOG`
(e.g. `RUST_LOG=debug`) and a live look into the formatter progress.
Default:
`RUST_LOG=debug`:
It's easy to see in this output which files take a disproportionate
amount of time.
[Peek 2023-07-30
14-35.webm](2c92db5c-1354-465b-a6bc-ddfb281d6f9d)
It opens up further integration with the tracing ecosystem,
[tracing-timing](https://docs.rs/tracing-timing/latest/tracing_timing/)
and [tokio-console](https://github.com/tokio-rs/console) can e.g. show
histograms and the json output allows us building better pipelines than
grepping a log file.
One caveat is using `parent: None` for the logging statements because
tracing subscriber does not allow deactivating the span without
reimplementing all the other log message formatting, too, and we don't
need span information, esp. since it would currently show the progress
bar span.
## Test Plan
n/a
**Summary** This includes two changes:
* Allow setting `-v` in `ruff_dev`, using the `ruff_cli` implementation
* `debug!` which ruff configuration strategy was used
This is a byproduct of debugging #6187.
**Test Plan** n/a
**Summary** Add a formatter progress testing script to CI. This script
will 1) print the black compability on each run 2) catch regressions wrt
to formatter stability, emitting invalid syntax and other kinds of bugs
(e.g. #5917) before they land on main 3) have an additional layer of
real world tests when implementing new nodes or other new formatter
code.
This is currently a bash script, i'm not sure if we want to keep it that
way, or switch to e.g. the regular ecosystem scripts. The output
separation of `format_dev` could also use some polishing. We should also
consider pinning commits so we don't get spurious regression when they
change their code.
**Test Plan** The script extends CI.
## Summary
For formatter instabilities, the message we get look something like
this:
```text
Unstable formatting /home/konsti/ruff/target/checkouts/deepmodeling:dpdispatcher/dpdispatcher/slurm.py
@@ -47,9 +47,9 @@
- script_header_dict["slurm_partition_line"] = (
- NOT_YET_IMPLEMENTED_ExprJoinedStr
- )
+ script_header_dict[
+ "slurm_partition_line"
+ ] = NOT_YET_IMPLEMENTED_ExprJoinedStr
Unstable formatting /home/konsti/ruff/target/checkouts/deepmodeling:dpdispatcher/dpdispatcher/pbs.py
@@ -26,9 +26,9 @@
- pbs_script_header_dict["select_node_line"] += (
- NOT_YET_IMPLEMENTED_ExprJoinedStr
- )
+ pbs_script_header_dict[
+ "select_node_line"
+ ] += NOT_YET_IMPLEMENTED_ExprJoinedStr
```
For ruff crashes. you don't even get that but just the file that crashed
it. To extract the actual bug, you'd need to manually remove parts of
the file, rerun to see if the bug still occurs (and revert if it
doesn't) until you have a minimal example.
With this script, you run
```shell
cargo run --bin ruff_shrinking -- target/checkouts/deepmodeling:dpdispatcher/dpdispatcher/slurm.py target/minirepo/code.py "Unstable formatting" "target/debug/ruff_dev format-dev --stability-check target/minirepo"
```
and get
```python
class Slurm():
def gen_script_header(self, job):
if resources.queue_name != "":
script_header_dict["slurm_partition_line"] = f"#SBATCH --partition {resources.queue_name}"
```
which is an nice minimal example.
I've been using this script and it would be easier for me if this were
part of main. The main disadvantage to merging is that it adds
additional dependencies.
## Test Plan
I've been using this for a number of minimization. This is an internal
helper script you only run manually. I could add a test that minimizes a
rule violation if required.
---------
Co-authored-by: Micha Reiser <micha@reiser.io>
## Summary
Comparing repos with black requires that we use the settings as black,
notably line length and magic trailing comma behaviour. Excludes and
preserving quotes (vs. a preference for either quote style) is not yet
implemented because they weren't needed for the test projects.
In the other two commits i fixed the output when the progress bar is
hidden (this way is recommonded in the indicatif docs), added a
`scratch.pyi` file to gitignore because black formats stub files
differently and also updated the ecosystem readme with the projects json
without forks.
## Test Plan
I added a `line-length` vs `line_length` test. Otherwise only my
personal usage atm, a PR to integrate the script into the CI to check
some projects will follow.
## Summary
The similarity index, the fraction of unchanged lines, is easier to
understand than the jaccard index, the fraction between intersection and
union.
## Test Plan
I ran this on django and git a 0.945 index, meaning 5.5% of lines are
currently reformatted when compared to black
## Summary
This extends the `ruff_dev` formatter script util. Instead of only doing
stability checks, you can now choose different compatible options on the
CLI and get statistics.
* It adds an option the formats all files that ruff would check to allow
looking at an entire black-formatted repository with `git diff`
* It computes the [Jaccard
index](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jaccard_index) as a measure of
deviation between input and output, which is useful as single number
metric for assessing our current deviations from black.
* It adds progress bars to both the single projects as well as the
multi-project mode.
* It adds an option to write the multi-project output to a file
Sample usage:
```
$ cargo run --bin ruff_dev -- format-dev --stability-check crates/ruff/resources/test/cpython
$ cargo run --bin ruff_dev -- format-dev --stability-check /home/konsti/projects/django
Syntax error in /home/konsti/projects/django/tests/test_runner_apps/tagged/tests_syntax_error.py: source contains syntax errors (parser error): BaseError { error: UnrecognizedToken(Name { name: "syntax_error" }, None), offset: 131, source_path: "<filename>" }
Found 0 stability errors in 2755 files (jaccard index 0.911) in 9.75s
$ cargo run --bin ruff_dev -- format-dev --write /home/konsti/projects/django
```
Options:
```
Several utils related to the formatter which can be run on one or more repositories. The selected set of files in a repository is the same as for `ruff check`.
* Check formatter stability: Format a repository twice and ensure that it looks that the first and second formatting look the same. * Format: Format the files in a repository to be able to check them with `git diff` * Statistics: The subcommand the Jaccard index between the (assumed to be black formatted) input and the ruff formatted output
Usage: ruff_dev format-dev [OPTIONS] [FILES]...
Arguments:
[FILES]...
Like `ruff check`'s files. See `--multi-project` if you want to format an ecosystem checkout
Options:
--stability-check
Check stability
We want to ensure that once formatted content stays the same when formatted again, which is known as formatter stability or formatter idempotency, and that the formatter prints syntactically valid code. As our test cases cover only a limited amount of code, this allows checking entire repositories.
--write
Format the files. Without this flag, the python files are not modified
--format <FORMAT>
Control the verbosity of the output
[default: default]
Possible values:
- minimal: Filenames only
- default: Filenames and reduced diff
- full: Full diff and invalid code
-x, --exit-first-error
Print only the first error and exit, `-x` is same as pytest
--multi-project
Checks each project inside a directory, useful e.g. if you want to check all of the ecosystem checkouts
--error-file <ERROR_FILE>
Write all errors to this file in addition to stdout. Only used in multi-project mode
```
## Test Plan
I ran this on django (2755 files, jaccard index 0.911) and discovered a
magic trailing comma problem and that we really needed to implement
import formatting. I ran the script on cpython to identify
https://github.com/astral-sh/ruff/pull/5558.
