diff --git a/lua/snacks/gh/api.lua b/lua/snacks/gh/api.lua
index 928cd467..e44758e4 100644
--- a/lua/snacks/gh/api.lua
+++ b/lua/snacks/gh/api.lua
@@ -464,6 +464,7 @@ function M.comments(item, cb)
                 state
                 commit { oid }
                 submittedAt
+                createdAt
                 reactionGroups {
                   content
                   users { totalCount }
diff --git a/lua/snacks/gh/item.lua b/lua/snacks/gh/item.lua
index 5d4afec8..ecd6ae95 100644
--- a/lua/snacks/gh/item.lua
+++ b/lua/snacks/gh/item.lua
@@ -126,7 +126,6 @@ function M:update(data, fields)
   vim.tbl_map(fix, item.comments or {})
   for _, review in ipairs(item.reviews or {}) do
     fix(review)
-    review.created = review.submitted
     vim.tbl_map(fix, review.comments or {})
   end
 
diff --git a/lua/snacks/gh/render/init.lua b/lua/snacks/gh/render/init.lua
index 0d6e6a89..79abf6f8 100644
--- a/lua/snacks/gh/render/init.lua
+++ b/lua/snacks/gh/render/init.lua
@@ -302,13 +302,12 @@ function M.render(buf, item, opts)
     for _, thread in ipairs(threads) do
       local c = #lines
 
-      if thread.submitted then
+      ctx.is_review = thread.state ~= nil
+      if ctx.is_review then
         ---@cast thread snacks.gh.Review
-        ctx.is_review = true
         vim.list_extend(lines, M.review(thread, ctx))
       else
         ---@cast thread snacks.gh.Comment
-        ctx.is_review = false
         vim.list_extend(lines, M.comment(thread, ctx))
       end
 
diff --git a/lua/snacks/gh/types.lua b/lua/snacks/gh/types.lua
index 73a5d911..0b76592c 100644
--- a/lua/snacks/gh/types.lua
+++ b/lua/snacks/gh/types.lua
@@ -100,6 +100,7 @@
 ---@field author snacks.gh.User
 ---@field authorAssociation string
 ---@field body string
+---@field createdAt string
 ---@field submittedAt string
 ---@field submitted number
 ---@field created number
@@ -108,7 +109,7 @@
 ---@field commit? {oid: string}
 ---@field comments? snacks.gh.Comment[]
 
----@alias snacks.gh.Thread snacks.gh.Comment|snacks.gh.Review|{created: number}
+---@alias snacks.gh.Thread snacks.gh.Comment|snacks.gh.Review
 
 ---@class snacks.gh.Item
 ---@field number number